Princess Peach Showtime Review: Hi-Yo Silver

Prairie Grown Reviews is reader-supported. When you purchase something through our links we may earn an affiliate commission.

Princess Peach: Showtime is a delightful addition to Nintendo’s ever-expanding catalog, offering a fresh take on platforming while putting Princess Peach in the well-deserved spotlight. With its unique levels, vibrant visuals, and engaging gameplay, the game delivers a fun, albeit not overly challenging, experience that feels both familiar and refreshing.

Before we get into my thoughts on Princess Peach: Showtime, there’s only caveat I want to make. This game is a ton of fun, but 79.99 CAD is terrible. Nintendo has done this on more than a handful of occasions, but paying full price for this game is really hard to justify. It’s worth playing if you got unlimited game money, a library or some form of rental service nearby, or multiple people willing to play, but 79.99 is impossible for me to support.

Set in the captivating world of Sparkle Theatre, the game follows Princess Peach and her companion, Stella, as they work to reclaim the theatre from the clutches of Madame Grape. Each stage brings a new twist, with distinct paths that not only keep the gameplay exciting but also showcase the creativity of the development team. The theatrical setting is more than just a backdrop; it allows for a diverse array of levels and scenarios, each more imaginative than the last.

The best part of Princess Peach: Showtime is how effortlessly it draws players in. The game’s structure is perfect for quick, casual play, yet its varied challenges make it hard to put down. The premise of transforming Peach into different roles—Detective, Ninja, Cowgirl, and more—elevates the gameplay to a new level. Each transformation introduces unique mechanics and gameplay styles, ensuring that the experience feels fresh throughout.

Detective Peach, for instance, adds a puzzle-solving element, encouraging players to think through scenarios and piece together clues. It’s a refreshing change of pace that keeps players on their toes. Ninja Peach, on the other hand, brings stealth mechanics into play, requiring precision and timing. This role introduces an element of strategy, as players must carefully navigate the environment to avoid detection. Meanwhile, Cowgirl Peach offers a fast-paced, arcade-like experience reminiscent of endless runner games, complete with quick reactions and a dynamic flow.

Even the baking levels bring a surprising amount of engagement and charm, blending creativity with timed challenges. Watching Peach take on such diverse roles is a testament to the thought and effort that went into making each level feel distinct. The transformations aren’t just cosmetic—they fundamentally change how you approach each stage, making the game feel like a series of mini-adventures.

The mix of 2D and 3D gameplay further enhances the experience. Some transformations lean heavily on one format, while others seamlessly blend the two, adding layers of depth and variety. This thoughtful design ensures that every level feels distinct and keeps players eager for what’s next. It also allows Princess Peach: Showtime to experiment with perspective and gameplay mechanics in a way that keeps things visually and mechanically engaging.

While Princess Peach: Showtime excels in many areas, it does have its shortcomings. The story, while serviceable, lacks the depth and twists that could have made the journey more compelling. Comparing to Super Mario Odyssey, which is just stuff with content, Princess Peach: Showtime feels short. The premise of Sparkle Theatre being taken over by Madame Grape is engaging enough to set the stage, but the narrative doesn’t develop much beyond that. The progression is straightforward—clear a floor, defeat the boss, move up—and could have benefited from a few surprises or narrative twists to add tension and stakes.

This simplicity in storytelling might not detract for younger players or those looking for pure gameplay, but for those seeking a more immersive experience, it feels like a missed opportunity. The setting is undeniably charming, but it’s the gameplay, not the story, that carries the game. A few more narrative wrinkles—like unexpected setbacks or deeper character development—could have made the journey through Sparkle Theatre even more memorable.

Another area where the game falls short is in its level of difficulty. Nintendo has a reputation for crafting accessible games, and while this ensures that Princess Peach: Showtime appeals to a broad audience, it also means that puzzles and challenges rarely push players to their limits. For experienced gamers, the lack of difficulty may leave the experience feeling somewhat shallow. A touch more complexity in certain levels or boss fights could have elevated the overall experience and provided a greater sense of accomplishment.

That being said, the game is brimming with memorable moments. The boss fights, in particular, are a highlight, each showcasing the game’s vibrant art style and clever mechanics. Every encounter feels polished and purposeful, and the finale is equally impressive, tying together the game’s theatrical theme with flair. The attention to detail in these battles, combined with the dynamic level designs, ensures that players stay engaged.

Visually, Princess Peach: Showtime is stunning. The art direction perfectly captures the theatrical theme, with each stage offering a vibrant and distinct look. Whether you’re exploring a ninja hideout, investigating a mystery as Detective Peach, or participating in a high-speed chase as Cowgirl Peach, the game’s visuals enhance the experience. The vibrant colors and detailed environments make Sparkle Theatre a joy to explore.

Ultimately, Princess Peach: Showtime is a joy to play. It’s approachable, creative, and offers a new perspective by putting Princess Peach at the center of the action. While it doesn’t revolutionize platforming or storytelling, it shines brightly as a fun and unique experience. The game succeeds in giving Princess Peach her moment in the spotlight, proving that she’s more than capable of leading her own adventure.

For those looking for a lighthearted, creative platformer with plenty of charm, Princess Peach: Showtime is well worth playing. The game might not challenge seasoned gamers or deliver a groundbreaking narrative, but it more than makes up for it with its engaging gameplay, clever level design, and vibrant presentation.